durham public schools

[SoDu We Learn DPS Governance] What Test Scores Tell a DPS Board Member, and What They Don’t

State test scores can show progress, but they don’t tell the whole story. Here’s how a hypothetical first-year DPS board member might read the numbers, ask better questions, and look for what students need next.

Southpoint Access

Southpoint Access

— 11 min read
Share
[SoDu We Learn DPS Governance] What Test Scores Tell a DPS Board Member, and What They Don’t

This article is written from the viewpoint of a hypothetical first-year Durham Public Schools Board of Education member. It isn’t written by, endorsed by, or meant to represent any current or former board member. The goal is to help South Durham readers understand how a DPS board member might look at state test scores, school performance grades, academic growth, and other accountability data. Check out the ongoing series!

sodu we learn dps governance - Southpoint Access
Southpoint AccessWes Platt

State test scores can be tempting to read like a final answer.

A school is up. A school is down. A district is improving. A district is struggling. A letter grade looks good, bad, or somewhere in between.

But for a Durham Public Schools board member, the annual accountability release should not be treated as a scoreboard by itself. It should be treated as a map.

The numbers can show where students are meeting state benchmarks, where schools are growing students, where achievement gaps remain, where support is needed, and where the district may need to ask harder questions.

They also can be misunderstood.

A single number doesn't tell the full story of a school. A letter grade doesn't explain everything happening in classrooms. A districtwide gain can still hide uneven results. A school with strong growth may still have low proficiency. A school with high proficiency may not be growing every group of students well.

That's why a board member has to read the results carefully.

The goal isn't to use test scores to celebrate blindly or assign blame. The goal is to understand what the data says, what it does not say, and what Durham Public Schools should do next.

DPS reports test gains, tackles absences and pay
Durham Public Schools recorded its highest proficiency rate since 2014, but officials acknowledged challenges involving academic growth, chronic absenteeism, transportation, and classified employee wages.
Southpoint AccessWes Platt

Read more